The Game Is Afoot: The Nine Plot Points of a Mystery Novel

The Nine Plot Points of a Mystery Novel (how to structure mysteries for writers)

 

By David Griffin Brown

 

Are mysteries built like novels in other genres? To find out, we broke down sixteen titles from the mystery canon, plot point by plot point, starting with Poe’s The Murders in the Rue Morgue and ending with Flynn’s Gone Girl.

The answer: they are and they aren’t. A mystery has an inciting incident, a midpoint, and a climax, same as pretty much everything else on the shelf. But the plot points in a mystery have different jobs. In most fiction, structure follows a protagonist who changes. Sherlock Holmes is the same man on the last page as he was on the first. What changes in a mystery is the case: how much is known, how much is hidden, and how badly things have come apart. The arc primarily belongs to the reader—to the journey from chaos into order. Every plot point either adds to the chaos or clears some of it away.

(Primarily—We’re not suggesting a detective can’t have an arc. Plenty of modern ones do.)

Since the mystery plot points have different functions, we’ve given them different names. Here is the whole map, with the conventional term in brackets and The Hound of the Baskervilles as our example. Spoilers ahead, though you’ve had since 1902 to catch up.

1. The Detective and Their Methods (stasis)

Before anything goes wrong, we meet the person who will put it right. We get to see how they think. In other genres, this is a glimpse of ordinary life. The point, structurally, is to demonstrate an underlying motivation that will crystallize into a narrative goal and/or to establish what the protagonist stands to lose.

In a mystery’s version of stasis—and it’s worth noting that we clocked this plot point in pretty much every mystery we analyzed—we are introduced to the detective’s unique method or skill or perspective that will be instrumental in how they untangle the case that is about to stroll through their door.

Doyle opens with a walking stick left behind by a visitor. Holmes asks Watson what he can deduce from it. Watson does his best and gets nearly everything wrong, and Holmes corrects him with relish. Nobody has died yet, but we’re already sold on the deductive genius of the man who will solve the crime when it happens.

2. The Initial Puzzle (inciting incident)

Chaos arrives in the form of a crime.

Dr. Mortimer comes to Baker Street with a family legend about a spectral hound and the recent death of Sir Charles Baskerville. The official cause was heart failure. But Mortimer saw something near the body that he kept from the inquest: the footprints of a gigantic hound. Our hyper-rational detective now has an apparently supernatural death on his hands.

Just because a case has landed on the detective’s desk doesn’t mean they will necessarily agree to work it. Or that they are necessarily excited about it. And they need to be excited or eager or compelled in some way—because that sentiment will be contagious to readers.

3. Case Accepted (point of no return)

The detective takes the job, perhaps reluctantly, and then something makes this the one case they can’t walk away from. The structural purpose of this plot point is to intensify the stakes in some way. For example, there might end up being a personal element, a rivalry, or something about the crime that is irresistible for this particular detective.

Holmes agrees to help Dr. Mortimer out of curiosity. His true commitment comes shortly after, when a bearded stranger follows Sir Henry through London in a cab and spots Holmes before Holmes spots him. Later the cabbie reports that his fare claimed to be Sherlock himself. Now that Holmes has a cunning opponent who is taunting him, the case has become extra intriguing.

4. Gathering Evidence (rising action)

Rising action isn’t a single plot point. In most novels, rising action involves all the obstacles (internal and external) that the protagonist must overcome as they struggle and strive toward the narrative goal. That’s more or less the same in a mystery. The goal is the case’s solution, so the detective’s rising action includes interviews, clues, suspects, and red herrings.

Doyle hands this stretch to Watson, who goes to Baskerville Hall while Holmes claims to be busy in London. Watson diligently assembles the main facts of the case: a butler who creeps around at night, a woman sobbing in the dark, an escaped convict on the moor, a naturalist named Stapleton and his nervous sister, and a howl coming from the Grimpen Mire. Since he lacks Holmes’s knack for deduction, he doesn’t know what to make of any of this, and neither do we.

5. The Dead End (midpoint)

This is the classic moment when the case hits a wall… right before a breakthrough. Often there’s a second body, and the detective’s working theory is dashed.

Watson’s best lead is the butler, Barrymore. He and Sir Henry catch Barrymore signalling from a window with a candle, and for a moment it looks like the case is about to crack. But… nope. The escaped convict is Mrs. Barrymore’s brother, and the couple have been sneaking him food. The most suspicious man in the house has nothing to do with the murder. But in exchange for their silence, Barrymore offers a new lead: Sir Charles was due to meet a woman with the initials L.L. on the night he died. One line of inquiry closes and a better one opens.

It’s worth noting that this plot point only works with Watson as the detective. In most of Sherlock’s cases, the genius detective often has a pretty good idea what’s going on from the beginning. He spends the rising action assembling proofs of his theory—while keeping Watson and readers in the dark. The same thing is happening here. Holmes has already concluded about the score on the moor. As such, this Dead End plot point becomes much more common once Agatha Christie enters the scene with her "fair play" approach.

6. The Case Is Nearly Lost (all is lost)

This is when the detective comes as close as they ever will to failing, often by losing someone they were supposed to protect.

A mysterious figure Watson has seen on the moor turns out to be Holmes, who has been hiding there all along. He has barely finished telling Watson that Stapleton is their man when they hear a scream. They find Sir Henry’s body (or so they think) at the foot of a rock face. Holmes has failed his client. Then they turn the body over, and surprise, it’s not Sir Henry after all; it’s the convict wearing his clothes.

As the detective approaches the brink of failure, readers are primed for the maximum payoff when the case is finally solved.

7. The Final Puzzle Piece (the transformation)

The final piece of the puzzle is the one fact that brings the entire picture into focus. Hint: it almost always involves the motive.

Holmes knows whodunnit but not why. Back at Baskerville Hall, he notices a family portrait on the wall. Cover the hat and curls, and the face is Stapleton’s. Stapleton is a Baskerville, and with Sir Charles and Sir Henry dead, he stands to inherit everything.

8. Nabbing the Culprit (climax)

The detective names the guilty party. Order is restored.

Holmes has the case worked out, but he still needs to catch the villain in the act. So he sets a trap with Sir Henry as bait. Sir Henry walks home across the moor after dining with the Stapletons. A fog rolls in. A giant hound with glowing jaws comes out of it, and Holmes manages to shoot it in the nick of time. Stapleton flees into the Grimpen Mire, only to be swallowed by swampy quicksand.

9. Reviewing the Evidence (resolution)

This is when the detective gets to show off with an overview of how it all went down. It’s also the reader’s chance to walk back through the story and see it in order for the first time.

Back in London, Holmes lays it all out for us. Stapleton was the secret son of the family’s black sheep, his “sister” was actually his wife, and the hound was real all along, kept starved and painted with glowing phosphorus. Every detail from Watson’s reports gets its explanation.

Mysteries That Break the Mould

The mystery novel is a celebration of structural tropes. But that’s not to say every one of them needs to hit all of these plot points. As with all fiction, story structure connects directly to a reader’s emotional draw. So there is a psychological reason for them, but they don’t all need to appear, and the order can be manipulated.

Murder on the Orient Express drops its final puzzle piece near the middle of the book, when Poirot catches an inconsistency in one passenger’s story. The second half is spent confirming what he suspects.

In A Is for Alibi, Kinsey Millhone turns the case down at first. When she finally accepts, it’s because of a second murder with the same method, so accepting the case and being unable to walk away from it happen in the same moment.

And Then There Were None has no detective at all, so there are no methods to show and no case to accept. The killer explains everything himself in a confession sealed in a bottle.

Noir is a big exception since it has more in common structurally with an adventure story. In The Big Sleep, the initial puzzle (who is blackmailing General Sternwood?) is settled early. The case keeps resetting, and what holds the book together is Marlowe’s code. In the end, order is only partly restored: Marlowe discovers the truth and decides not to hand it over to the police.

And some books change genre halfway. Gone Girl plays out as a mystery until the midpoint, when we learn Amy is alive and framing her husband. The question changes from what happened to what will happen next, which means the second half is a thriller.

But these nine plot points are a map of the direction most mysteries take. Feel free to break the mould, as long as you know what you’re skipping, merging, or subverting—and why.


David Griffin Brown (Septimus Brown) is the founder and senior editor at Darling Axe Editing

David Griffin Brown is an award-winning short fiction writer and co-author of Immersion and Emotion: The Two Pillars of Storytelling, Story Skeleton: The Classics, and Fake Query Letters by Dead Authors. He holds a BA in anthropology from UVic and an MFA in creative writing from UBC, and his work has appeared in literary magazines such as the Malahat Review, White Wall Review, and Grain. He has published three novels: When the Sky Breaks, We've Come for Your Eggs, and No Country for Old Dragons. David founded Darling Axe Editing in 2018, and as part of his Book Broker interview series, he has compiled querying advice from over 100 literary agents. As an editor, he pays special attention to structure, relationship arcs, and voice. David lives in Victoria, Canada, on the traditional territory of the Songhees and Kosapsum Nations.

Immersion & Emotion: The Two Pillars of Storytelling

About the Darling Axe

Our editors are industry professionals and award-winning writers. We offer narrative development, editing, and coaching for every stage of your manuscript's journey to publication.


Work with a professional fiction editor from the Darling Axe: manuscript development and book editing services

Fake Query Letters by Dead Authors

Work with a professional fiction editor from the Darling Axe: manuscript development and book editing services


Book a sample edit with a professional fiction editor from the Darling Axe: manuscript development and book editing services



Darling Axe Academy – Query Quest: a self-paced querying course

Related Posts

Mystery’s Stasis: The Detective and Their Methods
Mystery’s Stasis: The Detective and Their Methods
Mystery runs on a particular fantasy: the deliverance of order out of chaos. No matter how bad the mess gets, the detect
Read More
Aristotle Says Your Novel Should Be a Symphony
Aristotle Says Your Novel Should Be a Symphony
Maybe your protagonist has a great backstory, an evocative subplot, or a fascinating side quest, but if none of these el
Read More
The Ring of Truth: On Creating Authenticity in Fiction
The Ring of Truth: On Creating Authenticity in Fiction
The quality we’re striving for in fiction maybe above all else is authenticity. We want our work to have the ring of tru
Read More

Leave a comment

Name .
.
Message .

Thanks! Your comment has been submitted for approval. Please be patient while we weed out the spam ♥